
It was really cute when my first daughter was an infant and she began to suck her thumb. It was also very convenient not to deal with pacifiers - the thumb is always available and never gets lost in a crib at night or falls out and the baby can't get it back in, nor does it fall on the filthy floor of restaurants or stores. Then daughter #3 comes along and sucks two of her fingers - yes, cute.
Now these very cute girls are 3 1/2 and almost 4-years old. For the past six months we have tried rational discussions about the negative effects of thumbsucking, showed them photos online of what braces look like, and painted their nails with "the yucky stuff" as they call it (some foul tasting cactus extract for nail biters or thumb suckers...our pediadontist swore by it). They cried at the taste initially but eventually acquired a taste for it. Then we even resorted to taking a sock and covering their hand in it, then DUCT taping it so that they could not remove the sock. This has worked successfully with Claire so far. She is two weeks and going strong. But our sweet Lily - she is tenacious! She will chew, tear, and bite her way through any amount of tape.
I love her tenacity - except when it comes to thumbsucking. I ordered ThumbGuard for her - guaranteed that a child can not remove it. Except that Lily is like Houdini and has removed it already five times in the past 3 days. We've not had one successful night. I even took her to the toy store to pick out a handful of toys to be used as bribes - for each night that she keeps it on all night, she gets to pick a toy at breakfast. No luck yet.
I feel like I'm going to pull my hair out. It's so hard to know when and how hard to push our kids. Poor kiddo. I know it's so hard for her. I just have no idea how else to help her on this except to keep plugging away and encouraging her. So if any of you have bright ideas to share, help!









